Content Organization Is the Secret to a Blog That Makes Sense
Wondering why your blog feels scattered? Learn how poor content organization shows up over time and why every blog post should have a purpose.
Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links, meaning if you decide to make a purchase after clicking my website links, I may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. See my disclaimer for more info.
I look at a LOT of websites. Sometimes people hire me because they want more traffic, sometimes they’re launching a new offer, and sometimes Google has absolutely humbled them or they’re feeling overwhelmed and disconnected and they’re hoping I can figure out why. Before I ever open a keyword research tool or Google Search Console, I almost always do the same thing: start a mental content organization inventory. I log into WordPress (Or Shopify. Or Squarespace. Same kinda system just different buttons.) and then I start poking around like a millennial looking for some guy named John Doe on Facebook who wears a blue t-shirt and their BFF needs the full rundown. Anyways.
I’ll open the Posts tab and it’s just… a list. Fifty blog posts, everything sitting in Uncategorized, publish dates from 2022, half the meta descriptions blank. Then I’ll ask where they keep track of their content, and usually I get a laugh. “Oh… I don’t.” Or, “I think I have a spreadsheet somewhere?” Or my personal favorite, “I just write whatever I think of.”
And every single time I have the same thought. This isn’t a content creation problem and it most likely isn’t a keyword problem either. It’s a content organization problem. If I can’t tell what’s going on in your posts, neither can your readers and neither can any search engine or LLM trying to figure out who you are.
The First Signs Your Content Organization Is Non-Existent
People hear “content organization” and immediately picture some wildly detailed Notion dashboard with color coding and twelve different tags. Bless them, seriously. I’m not a Notion person whatsoever (I like Airtable!) but that’s honestly only one piece of the puzzle.
What I mean when I say content organization is knowing what content you already have, like your actual inventory. Knowing why you wrote it, what it’s supposed to do, and how it connects to everything else on your website. Your supply, the stockroom you pull from, or whatever you call it. Pantry, cupboard, etc.
From where I’m sitting, I don’t usually see businesses that haven’t worked hard. I see businesses that have been blogging for YEARS. They’ve put in the effort, written dozens of posts, created genuinely helpful resources. Then nobody stopped to zoom out and ask, “What exactly have we built?”
What Disorganized Blog Content Looks Like
One of the easiest tells is the publish dates. Sometimes they’re BEAUTIFUL. Every Tuesday, every Thursday, every week. “WE’RE DOING CONTENT!” Then nothing. No gradual slowdown, no pivot, just complete silence.
Honestly, it makes me kind of sad because I can almost pinpoint the moment someone got overwhelmed because I know it all too well. The system stopped making sense to them and their brain said nope no thank you, not computing. Because if every new article feels like throwing another box into an already overflowing garage, eventually you stop opening the garage.
Everything Is Educational
Another thing I notice? Everything is educational. Everything. Every post answers a beginner question. Every post explains something someone could probably learn from three Instagram carousels and a TikTok.
Now before anyone comes for me, I LOVE educational content. I literally make educational content for a living. But blogs get to do something social media can’t. They get to go deeper. Someone should leave your blog thinking about the topic differently than when they arrived. That’s the magic. If every article stays at surface level, your readers never really get to know how you think.
Why So Much Blog Content Feels Generic
This one happens constantly. I’ll read one article and think, “WOW. This is fantastic.” It’s opinionated, specific, clearly written by someone who’s actually done the thing they’re talking about. Then the very next article feels like it belongs on an entirely different website. Five generic productivity tips. Ten ways to improve your marketing. Seven mistakes to avoid. Nothing technically wrong with them, nothing memorable either.
The frustrating part? The really good posts usually have almost no SEO consideration behind them, so nobody finds them. The generic ones are targeting keywords that don’t actually move the business forward. It’s backwards.
Every Blog Post Should Have a Job
This is probably the question I mentally note to myself more than anything else during an audit. What job does this post have? Not what keyword is it targeting, not how many words it has. What job is it actually doing?
Is it attracting someone new? Answering a buying question? Building trust? Supporting one of your offers? Helping someone take the next step? Or does it just… exist?
Sure, you can have a few “just for fun” posts and I’ll be the first one to admit that I’m not even the best rule follower over here. Some posts should absolutely bring in people who’ve never heard of you. Some should nurture. Some should answer objections. Some should make someone think, “Okay… this person actually knows what they’re talking about.” Some should naturally lead into an offer. (If I was going to plead my case, every single post should lead into some kind of offer even if it’s just to join your world.)
Instead, I often see websites where every article is trying to be the exact same kind of educational post. The same “how to” or “this is what this is” flows through every single post. Everything lives at the awareness stage. Nobody ever gets invited further into the conversation or demonstrates what they’re capable of because everyone is A- too afraid to give away the milk for free and B- not aware of what exists already.
Content Problems I Routinely Notice During Every Website Audit
Then there are all the little tells. Three blog posts covering almost the exact same topic without linking to each other. A category with one lonely article because every new idea became a new bucket. An AMAZING post from three years ago that has never been updated even though it’d probably perform really well with a couple hours of work. Internal links pointing to pages that don’t exist anymore. Meta descriptions that were never written. Random formatting changes halfway through the blog because apparently we all discovered new fonts in 2021. (Again… same.)
None of those things are huge problems by themselves. Together? They tell a story. They tell me this website has been growing for years without anyone stepping back to look at the whole thing.
And honestly, I don’t judge that. Running a business is HARD. You’re serving clients, launching offers, answering emails, making content, and trying to have something resembling a personal life. Of course the blog slowly turns into a junk drawer. That’s the normal outcome.
Why Content Organization Matters More Than Most Businesses Realize
So I don’t usually think most businesses need another fifty blog posts. I think they need an afternoon where they stop writing. Seriously. STOP. Not forever, just long enough to look around.
The Garage Nobody Wants to Open
The best way I can explain it is this. Imagine opening your garage. Not the Pinterest garage. A real garage.
You’ve got camping gear you absolutely planned to use, holiday decorations, power tools, half-finished DIY projects, a bike missing one wheel, and a box labeled “Important” that nobody has opened since 2019. None of it’s garbage, it’s just all lost and forlorn strewn everywhere. You bought every single thing because it had a purpose. Life just… happened. So instead of organizing it, you kept adding new stuff until opening the garage felt overwhelming.
That’s what I see on a lot of websites. Just years of good intentions that just piled on top of one another over the years to the point where the OG good stuff isn’t even visible anymore because it’s been long forgotten about.
What’s the difference between content organization and content strategy?
Strategy is the plan for what you’re going to make. Organization is knowing what you’ve already got and what it’s doing. Most people jump straight to strategy (“what should I post next?”) without ever taking stock of the fifty posts already sitting on their site. That’s ass backwards. You can’t build a plan on top of content you can’t even see. Organization first, strategy second.
How do I know if my blog actually has an organization problem?
Open your Posts tab and try to answer one question: what is each post FOR? If you can’t say what job a post is doing, who it’s for, or how it connects to anything else on your site, that’s your answer. Other quick tells: everything’s in Uncategorized, you’ve got multiple posts on the same topic that don’t link to each other, or you genuinely forgot some of these posts existed.
Where do I start if all my posts are uncategorized?
Don’t reorganize yet. Just look. Pull every post into one simple list (a spreadsheet is fine, this is not the time for a fancy Notion build) and write down what each one is actually about and what you think its job is. That’s it.
Should I delete old blog posts or update them?
Depends on the post, and you can’t know until you’ve looked at it. A post that’s genuinely good but outdated is usually worth updating, sometimes it just needs a couple hours to perform again. Auditing a blog is a much more nuanced and in-depth topic that we can cover in a future post.
Can I fix my content organization myself, or do I need to hire someone?
You can absolutely start yourself. I’d recommend it because nobody knows your content better than you. The first pass is honestly just seeing what you have and what job each piece is doing, is something any business owner can do with Claude, an afternoon and a spreadsheet.
What Happens When You Finally Look
The answer isn’t buying another toolbox. The answer is opening the garage and looking around, picking stuff up and moving it to see what’s hiding.
Because once you know what’s there, you can decide what gets updated, what gets combined, what gets deleted, what supports your offers, and what deserves another chance. And maybe most importantly, what job each piece of content is supposed to have. Inventory allows you to see connections, flows, journeys and gaps. Inventory is creative freedom– CHANGE MY MIND.
If you got to the end of this thinking, “Okay… I feel a little attacked.” GOOD. Just kidding lol. I don’t want you to feel attacked because your website is broken per se, but noticing the pattern is the first step toward improving! You can’t fix anything until you know what’s going on. And ya can’t scale a broken website that’s cobbled together.
Honestly, I think a lot more of us have garage websites than we’d like to admit. Mine included. You should see my Instagram hahaha.
You’re invited!
If you chuckled over any of this thinking about your own content, I want you to come hang out in my newsletter. It’s called In Search Of, because I’m always ISO something. The best content advice, the best tools, the smartest ways to make what you already have actually work for you, a recipe for dinner. It’s also where I share more behind the scenes about what I’m up to in business and I absolutely love to share helpful content including (yep– going off the rails here!) recipes, SEO tips, content advice and chicken updates.
Sign up for In Search Of
An email newsletter dedicated to content and SEO marketing, the newest topics and creators to learn about and follow, and just genuinely helpful content marketing education and advice. Also probably recipes.
By signing up, you agree to the privacy policy. Unsubscribe any time.
Author: Julie Klemens
Julie Klemens is an SEO and content strategy consultant based outside Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. She does SEO and content work that helps you show up as the right person where your audience is actually looking — and that includes how you’re showing up across social media too. Before moving into full-service SEO, she worked exclusively with Pinterest, helping businesses and brands show up on the platform. And before that, she spent 12 years as a critical care nurse, which is a long way of saying she is very comfortable with complex problems, uncomfortable with shortcuts, and genuinely allergic to surface-level work. Her approach is diagnostic by nature and plain-spoken by choice. She explains what she finds, why it matters, and exactly what to do about it. Read more →
Hey there, I’m Julie, your BTS, always-in-search-of content hype friend. I’m a forever student of SEO, blogging, and content marketing, permanently in search of a better way. There’s a reason I’m this good at explaining the complicated parts.
Join the newsletter
In Search Of a Better Way?
Same. That’s why I send it every Sunday. SEO, blogging, and content marketing in plain language, plus the tools and rabbit holes worth your time. Fill in the form below and you’re in.
Search The Site
Featured Articles
No posts
Leave a Reply